Cheap Auto Insurance in Indiana for 2024 (Find Savings With These 10 Companies)

The top providers of cheap auto insurance in Indiana are Geico, Travelers, and Progressive, all offering highly competitive rates and excellent coverage options.

Geico is the number one best choice overall, with monthly premiums starting as low as $22. Travelers offer flexible coverage and discounts, while Progressive offers wide range of options for various driving practices such as safe driver and multiple policy discounts.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Cheap Auto Insurance in Indiana

These three insurers offer the best combination of low rates and reliable coverage, making them the top picks for affordable auto insurance in Indiana. Get fast and cheap auto insurance coverage today with our quote comparison tool above.

#1 – Geico: Top Pick Overall

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#2 – Travelers: Best for Flexible Options

Pros

• Coverage Options: Travelers offers roadside assistance and enhanced liability, catering to Indiana drivers. Their affordable auto insurance Elkhart Indiana option provides reasonable protection.
• Financial Stability: Travelers holds an A++ rating from A.M. Best, reflecting strong financial health and reliability. Gain a deeper understanding through our Travelers auto insurance review.
• Competitive Pricing: With premiums starting at $24 per month, Travelers offers cost-effective options for comprehensive protection.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Travelers’ total coverage premiums are higher than competitors, like Geico, which may not appeal to those seeking cheap car insurance Elkhart Indiana.
• Limited Local Access: Travelers has fewer agents in Indiana compared to State Farm, making in-person service harder to access.

#3 – Progressive: Best for Broad Coverage

Pros

• Wide Coverage: Progressive offers wide coverage that is perfect for someone looking for cheap car insurance in Gary, Indiana, where full coverage is needed.
• Affordable Rates: At $25 per month, Progressive provides competitive pricing for budget-conscious drivers.
• Strong Support: With an A+ rating from A.M. Best, Progressive ensures reliable customer service and claims processing.

Cons

• Premium Increases After Claims: Filing a claim may lead to higher premiums, which could be a drawback for those looking for car insurance in Lake Station at a consistent rate.
• Limited Discounts: Progressive offers fewer discounts than other insurance providers, leaving less room for savings. Obtain further insights from our Progressive Auto Insurance review.

#4 – Farmers: Best for Custom Policies

Pros

• Customizable Policies: Farmers offer flexible options like accident forgiveness and enhanced liability coverage, which is ideal for those seeking a personalized Indiana auto insurance plan.
• Affordable Premiums: At $27 per month, Farmers offers competitive rates. If you’re wondering how much is car insurance in Indiana, this is a budget-friendly option.
• Financial Stability: With an A rating from A.M. Best, Farmers offers reliable financial backing.

Cons

• Higher Rates for Young Drivers: Young drivers in Indiana may face higher premiums, which could be a downside in a Farmer’s auto insurance review.
• Limited Discounts: Farmers offer fewer discounts than other providers, which could limit savings for drivers in Indiana.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#5 – State Farm: Best for Local Presence

Pros

• Local Presence: As a network, State Farm is well established in Indiana, and in-person service for policyholders who prefer face-to-face interactions.
• Affordable Full Coverage: At $28 per month, State Farm provides cheap auto insurance in Indiana, making it a cost-effective choice for full coverage.
• Efficient Claims Handling: State Farm is known for quick claims processing, offering peace of mind with fast resolutions in auto insurance in Indiana.

Cons

• Lower Financial Rating: With a B rating from A.M. Best, State Farm’s financial stability may concern drivers seeking long-term security in their State Farm auto insurance review.
• Higher Coverage Costs: State Farm collision and comprehensive coverage tend to cost more than other insurers. For those budget-conscious drivers, this might not be within their budget.

#6 – Mercury: Best for Affordable Rates

Pros

• Affordable Rates: Mercury offers premiums as low as $30 per month, providing affordable auto insurance Elkhart IN for drivers aiming to save on coverage.
• Safe Driver Discounts: Policyholders with clean records receive discounts, making Mercury a solid choice in this Mercury auto insurance review.
• Financial Stability: This guarantee of reliability by A.M. Best can be described as an A rating for Mercury, therefore showing how reliable it is for Indiana drivers.

Cons

• Limited Coverage Options: Mercury has fewer coverage choices compared to other insurers, which may be less ideal for drivers seeking classic auto insurance Gary Indiana.
• Less Competitive Multi-Car Discount: The multi-car discount Mercury offers is not as powerful as other insurers do, which would affect households that have more than one vehicle.

#7 – Nationwide: Best for Bundling Benefits

Pros

• Bundling Discounts: Nationwide offers savings for Indiana drivers who combine Nationwide auto insurance review with home insurance or insure multiple vehicles.
• Strong Financial Stability: Nationwide’s A+ rating from A.M. Best reassures Indiana policyholders of its financial health and ability to manage claims.
• Competitive Rates: At an average of $33 per month, Nationwide provides affordable premiums with attractive Indiana auto insurance rates.

Cons

• Higher Premiums for Younger Drivers: Nationwide’s rates for young drivers may be higher, pushing them toward other car insurance in Kendallville.
• Limited Local Offices: Nationwide has fewer branches in Indiana than providers like State Farm, limiting in-person support options.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#8 – American Family: Best for Loyalty Discounts

Pros

• Loyalty Discounts: This American Family auto insurance review highlights loyalty discounts for long-term Indiana policyholders, helping them save over time.
• Affordable Rates for Young Drivers: American Family can provide relatively cheap quotations on car insurance coverage for young drivers. For instance, one pays only $37 monthly. It might be the best for car insurance in Ellettsville.
• Comprehensive Coverage Options: The American Family provides extensive coverage choices to protect drivers from various risks.

Cons

• Limited Safe Driver Discounts: American Family offers fewer discounts for safe drivers, which may be a drawback for those with clean records seeking car insurance in Nappanee.
• Higher Full Coverage Premiums: Full coverage premiums are higher than those of some competitors, which may not suit budget-conscious drivers.

#9 – Allstate: Best for Drivewise Program

Pros

• Drivewise Program: Allstate’s Drivewise program rewards Indiana safe drivers by offering discounts for operating a vehicle in a judicious manner.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Allstate auto insurance review highlights various options, including accident forgiveness and roadside assistance for thorough protection.
• Strong Financial Rating: Allstate’s A+ rating from A.M. Best ensures financial reliability for Indiana policyholders.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: At $48 per month, Allstate’s premiums are high, which may be a concern for drivers in Allstate insurance Vincennes, Indiana, seeking more affordable options.
• Limited Local Agent Network: Allstate has fewer agents in regions like Allstate Insurance Crawfordsville, making in-person assistance less accessible.

#10 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Discount Options

Pros

•  Multiple Discount Opportunities: Liberty Mutual auto insurance review highlights various discounts that help Indiana drivers save on car insurance in Indiana.
•  Customizable Coverage: With options like accident forgiveness, car insurance Gas City residents can tailor their policies for added convenience.
•  Financial Stability: Liberty Mutual’s A rating from A.M. Best assures Indiana drivers of the company’s ability to manage claims effectively.

Cons

• High Premiums: At $63 per month, Liberty Mutual’s rates are higher than many options for those seeking Indiana cheap auto insurance.
• Limited Local Agents: Indiana drivers may find fewer agents available compared to companies like State Farm.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Indiana Car Insurance Coverage and Rates

Indiana auto insurance rates vary by provider and coverage level, with minimum coverage generally more affordable than full coverage. Geico offers some of the lowest rates, at $22 per month for minimum coverage and $63 for full coverage. Travelers also provide affordable options at $24 monthly for minimum and $69 for full.

Indiana Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Coverage Level

Allstate and Liberty Mutual are pricier, with Allstate charging $48 for minimum and $140 for full, while Liberty Mutual’s rates are $63 and $183.Indiana drivers should consider collision and comprehensive coverage, especially due to the state’s abundant wildlife.

Comprehensive coverage usually encompasses damage caused by hitting a large animal, while collision coverage applies to accidents involving other motor vehicles or road obstacles. In wildlife-related accidents, collision and comprehensive coverage offer essential financial protection. Comparing rates across providers can help drivers find the best fit.

Indiana Minimum Coverage

In Indiana, drivers are required to carry minimum automobile liability coverage, following the 25/50/25 rule. This includes $25,000 to cover injuries to one person, $50,000 for injuries to multiple people, and $25,000 for property damage.

This basic liability insurance ensures that if you’re at fault in an accident, the other party is compensated for damages like vehicle repairs, medical bills, and property damage, such as to a fence or light pole. Indiana follows an “at-fault” system, meaning the driver responsible for the accident must pay for the damages to the other vehicle and its occupants.

While automobile liability coverage helps cover these costs, it’s only effective up to the limits specified in your policy. If the damages exceed these limits, the driver at fault must pay the remaining costs out-of-pocket. Not having the required minimum coverage can lead to serious penalties, including the suspension of your driver’s license and vehicle registration for up to a year, especially after major traffic violations.

Fortunately, Indiana accepts electronic proof of insurance, which can be used to demonstrate compliance with the law. Use our free comparison tool below to see what auto insurance quotes look like in your area.

Best Indiana Car Insurance Companies

The largest car insurance companies in the U.S. are led by State Farm, which commands the largest market share at 24.05%, followed by Progressive at 11.35%, and Allstate at 7.61%. Other major insurers include Indiana Farm Bureau, Geico, Liberty Mutual, and American Family, with Auto-Owners Group holding the smallest share at 2.4%.

Auto Insurance Discounts From the Top Providers in Indiana

According to J.D. Power, even though the market share is small, auto owners dominate the industry when it comes to customer satisfaction. State Farm and Progressive have a respective 35% market share summing up and thus penetrate the industry very steeply. In the state of Indiana, some of the leading car insurance companies provide various discounts that make these companies attract and maintain their customers.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Largest Car Insurance Companies

Allstate provides discounts for safe drivers, new vehicles, and good students, while Geico offers a defensive driving discount, as well as discounts for military personnel and anti-theft devices. Companies like Progressive, State Farm, and Liberty Mutual also feature discounts for policy bundling, good drivers, and multi-vehicle insurance.

These discounts help make coverage more affordable for a wide range of customers. Moreover, clever marketing campaigns, such as Progressive’s Flo, Geico’s Gecko, and State Farm’s celebrity endorsements, make the otherwise complex theme of car insurance interesting and accessible to consumers.

Find the Cheapest Insurance in Indiana Cities

Securing affordable auto insurance is essential to protect your finances and ensure adequate coverage. Since rates can vary widely by location, it’s helpful to compare options to find the best deal for your area.

Follow this quick guide to discover the most cost-effective auto insurance in your city.

• Recognize the Importance of Rate Comparisons: Insurance premiums vary with location; therefore, a comparison of rates is necessary in order to find the right deal in your area.
• Evaluate Rates Across Key Indiana Cities: Start by examining rates in Indiana cities like Evansville, Fort Wayne, Gary, Indianapolis, and South Bend to understand typical costs.
• Spot the Most Affordable Options: Use this information to identify the policies that provide great value without breaking the bank.
• Verify Comprehensive Coverage: While affordable rates are important, make sure the policy you choose offers the coverage you need.
• Select the Optimal Plan: After reviewing rates and coverage, choose the policy that provides both value and security.

By following this 10-minute auto insurance buying guide, you can quickly and confidently find the most affordable insurance options in your city without sacrificing necessary coverage. Take the time to compare and pick the best fit for peace of mind on the road.

Affordable Auto Insurance in Indiana: Top Picks and Savings Tips

Indiana drivers looking for budget-friendly auto insurance will find top rates with Geico, Travelers, and Progressive, where minimum coverage starts at $22, $24, and $25 per month. State laws require minimum liability coverage of 25/50/25, covering $25,000 for individual injuries, $50,000 for multiple injuries, and $25,000 for property damage.

Due to Indiana’s wildlife, adding collision and comprehensive coverage is recommended. Insurers offer several savings options, such as the anti-theft device discount, safe driver incentives, and discounts for bundling multiple policies. Use our free comparison tool below to see what auto insurance quotes look like in your area.